A crash is stressful enough without wondering whether you are "allowed" to take your car where you want. Many drivers in Bradenton and across Manatee County hear a shop name from their adjuster and assume they have to go there. Florida law and the insurers' own published claim policies paint a different picture. This page lays out what the Florida Statutes actually say, what your written estimate rights are under the state's repair law, and how Firkins Collision Center helps you through a claim once you have picked us.
This is general information, not legal advice. If you have a dispute over a specific claim, the Florida Department of Financial Services runs a free consumer helpline, listed near the end of this page.
The Short Answer
You are the vehicle owner. Insurers commonly maintain networks or "program" shops and will happily suggest one, but recommending a shop is not the same as requiring you to use it. Several of the largest insurers in Florida say directly on their claim pages that you can use any repair shop you like. You can read how that works with specific companies on our pages for State Farm, GEICO, Progressive, Allstate, USAA and Liberty Mutual.
What the network choice usually changes is the paperwork: who the insurer pays, which warranty applies, and whether any insurer-specific perks come with the repair. Ask your adjuster to explain those differences so you can decide with full information.
What Florida Law Says About Claim Settlement
Florida's rules for settling auto insurance claims are in section 626.9743, Florida Statutes. It applies to both personal and commercial motor vehicle claims. Several parts matter directly to collision repairs.
If an insurer requires a particular shop
Subsection (3) addresses the situation where an insurer elects to repair a vehicle and specifically requires a particular repair shop. In that case the insurer must make sure the vehicle is restored to its pre-loss performance and appearance at no additional cost to you beyond what your policy states (your deductible, for example). In other words, if an insurer insists on a specific shop, it takes on responsibility for the result.
Parts must be of like kind and quality
Subsection (4) says an insurer may not require the use of replacement parts that are not at least equivalent in kind and quality to the damaged parts before the loss. Separately, section 501.33 requires a written estimate that is based on non-OEM aftermarket crash parts to identify those parts and include a printed disclosure. That disclosure lets you see exactly what is being proposed. Firkins uses OEM parts whenever possible; our blog post on OEM vs aftermarket parts explains the trade-offs.
You can see the estimate behind your settlement
When a partial loss is settled based on a written estimate, subsection (7) requires the insurer to supply you a copy of the estimate the settlement is based on. If the insurer takes a deduction, subsection (6) says the basis must be explained to you in writing if you request it.
Protection for third-party claimants
If someone else hit you, subsection (2) says that when liability and damages are reasonably clear, an insurer may not recommend that you make a claim under your own policy solely to avoid paying the claim under the policy it issued. The insurer may still identify repair options for you, but the choice remains yours.
Your Written Estimate Rights Under the Motor Vehicle Repair Act
Florida's Motor Vehicle Repair Act (Part IX of Chapter 559) covers repair shops, and its definitions expressly include body work and paint and body shops. Key protections include:
| Your right | Where it comes from |
|---|---|
| A written estimate before work begins when repairs will exceed $150, with signed options you choose | s. 559.905 |
| The final bill cannot exceed the estimate by more than $10 or 10% (whichever is greater, capped at $50) without your approval | s. 559.909 |
| Prompt notice when added work is needed, so you can authorize, modify or cancel it | s. 559.909 |
| A shop may not hold your vehicle because you refuse to pay for unauthorized charges | s. 559.909 |
| You can ask, when you authorize repairs, to inspect or receive the parts that were replaced (with exceptions for warranty and exchange parts) | s. 559.909 |
| Storage charges cannot begin until 3 working days after you are told repairs are complete | s. 559.905 |
For collision work, the "notify and authorize" rule is the one you will notice most. Hidden damage is common once a bumper or panel comes off, so estimates often grow. Our article on why repair estimates change walks through what a supplement is and why it is normal.
How to Exercise Your Choice
- Report the claim with your insurer as soon as it is safe. Our guide to what to do after a car accident in Bradenton covers the scene, photos and information to collect.
- Tell the adjuster where you want the car repaired. A simple statement works: "I'd like my vehicle repaired at Firkins Collision Center, 2700 1st St, Bradenton."
- Ask the practical questions: Will payment go to me, the shop, or both (especially if you have a loan)? Does my policy include rental reimbursement? What warranty applies?
- Get a free estimate from us, either before or after the insurer's inspection.
- Approve the repair plan and let us coordinate supplements with the insurer as the work progresses.
How Firkins Collision Center Helps
We work with all insurance companies and provide insurance claim and paperwork assistance. When you choose us, we:
- Write a free, detailed estimate and send photos and documentation to your adjuster
- Disassemble and inspect for hidden damage, then submit supplements when needed
- Use OEM parts whenever possible, with on-site Mopar parts for Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep and Ram vehicles
- Repair structure with frame machines and computer-assisted measuring
- Offer free loaner vehicles or help arranging a rental, plus shuttle service and complimentary pickup and delivery
- Back our work with a lifetime warranty on parts and labor
If your car is not drivable, our 24-hour towing line is (941) 749-1450. Spanish-speaking staff are available at (941) 357-5162.
If You Have a Claim Problem
The Florida Department of Financial Services Division of Consumer Services offers a free Insurance Consumer Helpline at 1-877-693-5236. You can find contact options on the DFS consumer assistance page. For background, see our longer article on Florida's right to choose your body shop and our insurance claim help page.
Choose the Shop You Trust
Whether your claim is through your own policy or the other driver's, you can bring your vehicle to Firkins Collision Center. Schedule a free estimate or call (941) 229-6451. We are open Monday through Friday, 7:30 AM to 5:30 PM, and Saturday from 8:00 AM to noon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to use the body shop my insurance company recommends in Florida?
Insurers commonly offer a list of network or program shops, and several major insurers state on their own claim pages that you can use any shop you like. Choosing a network shop can come with insurer-specific perks, but it is not the only path. Tell your adjuster which shop you want to use and ask how payment will be handled.
What happens if my insurer requires a specific shop?
Under section 626.9743(3) of the Florida Statutes, an insurer that elects to repair a vehicle and specifically requires a particular repair shop must make sure the vehicle is restored to its pre-loss condition at no additional cost to you other than what your policy states, such as your deductible.
Can a Florida body shop charge more than the written estimate?
Under the Florida Motor Vehicle Repair Act, a shop generally cannot charge more than the written estimate by more than 10 dollars or 10 percent, whichever is greater, up to 50 dollars, unless you authorize the additional work. If hidden damage is found, the shop must contact you so you can approve, change or cancel the added repairs.
Can my insurer make the shop use aftermarket parts?
Florida law says an insurer may not require replacement parts that are not at least equal in kind and quality to the damaged parts before the loss. Florida also requires written disclosure when an estimate is based on non-OEM aftermarket crash parts, so you can see which parts are being proposed.
How do I tell my insurance company I want Firkins to fix my car?
When you report the claim, tell your adjuster you want your vehicle repaired at Firkins Collision Center in Bradenton and give them our phone number. We can coordinate the inspection, send photos and documentation, and handle supplements if hidden damage turns up.
What if the other driver's insurer is paying for my repairs?
You can still bring your vehicle to the shop you trust. Florida law also bars an insurer from recommending that a third-party claimant file under their own policy solely to avoid paying a claim when liability and damages are reasonably clear.
Wrecked, dented or scratched? Let's look at it.
Free estimates, help with your insurance claim, and a loaner while we work.